filmbriefs
all subjects →
13:00in productionCh. 1 · Neighbours, then not quite lovers/ 13:00 · ceiling 15 min
Romance · Drama

In the Mood for Love

Two neighbours whose spouses are sleeping together spend the film almost never touching, and Wong Kar-wai spends the whole two hours building on that restraint alone.

In 1962 Hong Kong, a newspaper editor and a secretary living next door to each other realise their spouses are having an affair, and grow close while insisting they will not repeat it. Wong Kar-wai shot for fifteen months without a finished script, switching cinematographers mid-production, and built the film around Maggie Cheung's cheongsams and Tony Leung's restraint rather than plot incident. It won Leung the Cannes best actor award and has since been ranked among the major works of Asian cinema.

Chapters & takeaways7
  1. 0:08
    Neighbours, then not quite lovers

    Chow Mo-wan and Su Li-zhen move into adjoining rented rooms on the same day in 1962, discover their spouses are having an affair with each other, and begin meeting to rehearse how the confrontation might go.

  2. 1:51
    A script that kept changing shape

    The film began as one strand of a larger, mainland-set project called Summer in Beijing that Wong abandoned; only the strand about a man and woman sharing noodles and secrets survived, relocated to 1960s Hong Kong.

  3. 3:43
    Cheung's cheongsams, Doyle's replacement

    Maggie Cheung wears a new qipao in nearly every scene, restricting her movement by design; Christopher Doyle shot most of the film before production ran long and Mark Lee Ping Bin finished it.

  4. 5:34
    Fifteen months, three cities

    Because 1960s Hong Kong no longer looked the part, Wong filmed exteriors and hotel scenes in Bangkok, a later sequence in Singapore, and closing shots at Angkor Wat, over a shoot that ran fifteen months without a locked script.

  5. 7:26
    What restraint is doing here

    Umebayashi's waltz theme and Chang's editing return to the same stairwell, the same noodle stall, the same slow-motion passes, turning repetition itself into the measure of how much the two central characters are holding back.

  6. 9:17
    Who this rewards

    Viewers patient with a story told through gesture and costume rather than dialogue will find it exceptional; anyone wanting the central relationship to become physical, or wanting a script that resolves its ambiguities, will be frustrated.

  7. 11:09
    Ninety-eight minutes, fully earned

    Short by arthouse standards and never padded, it won Leung a historic Cannes award and eight prizes from eighteen nominations, and the scores it has picked up since match a film that has only gained ground with time.

Worth your time?

Yes. Watch the whole thing.

5/ 5
What works
  • Cheung's costuming and physical performance
  • the corridor and stairwell photography
  • Umebayashi's recurring theme
  • Leung's Cannes-winning restraint
What does not
  • the plot's deliberate thinness may read as slightness rather than economy to some viewers
Watch it if
  • fans of restrained, atmosphere-driven romance
  • anyone interested in Hong Kong film of the period
  • viewers who appreciate costume and repetition as storytelling tools
Skip it if
  • viewers wanting overt physical or dialogue-driven romance
  • anyone impatient with slow, repetitive editing rhythms
The written brief4 min read

Neighbours, then not quite lovers

In the Mood for Love is set in 1962 Hong Kong and follows Chow Mo-wan, a newspaper editor played by Tony Leung, and Su Li-zhen, a secretary played by Maggie Cheung, who move into adjoining rooms on the same day and gradually work out that their respective spouses are having an affair with each other. Wong Kar-wai wrote and produced as well as directed, and the film became the second part of an informal trilogy either side of it, following Days of Being Wild and preceding 2046, sharing actors and a handful of unresolved plot threads between all three. Rather than dramatising the affair itself, the film sets out to watch two wronged people circle a relationship they keep insisting they will not let happen.

A script that kept changing shape

The project began under a different title, Summer in Beijing, conceived as a musical love story and partly shot without authorisation around Tiananmen Square before political sensitivities and Wong’s improvisational methods made a mainland shoot impractical. Wong had envisioned it as three linked stories; he kept only one, a strand then called A Story of Food about a man and woman sharing noodles and secrets, and relocated it to 1960s Hong Kong with Leung and Cheung already attached. The shoot ran fifteen months without a finished script, evolving as it went, and moved between locations standing in for a Hong Kong that had changed too much by 2000 to be filmed as itself: exteriors and hotel scenes in Bangkok, a later sequence in Singapore, and closing shots of Leung’s character at Angkor Wat.

Cheung’s cheongsams, Doyle’s replacement

Cheung’s performance is inseparable from her wardrobe: William Chang, credited as editor but also responsible for costume and production design, put her in a different qipao for nearly every scene, and the dresses restrict her stride and posture by design rather than incident. Christopher Doyle, on his sixth collaboration with Wong, shot most of the film in tight corridors and stairwells that keep the two leads close but rarely alone together, before production ran over schedule and Mark Lee Ping Bin, known for his work with Hou Hsiao-hsien, finished the remaining photography. Shigeru Umebayashi’s waltz theme recurs over slow-motion passes of Su carrying noodles down the same stairwell, turning a single repeated errand into the film’s clearest expression of routine standing in for restraint.

Fifteen months, three cities

The film asks a viewer to accept that almost nothing happens between its two leads for most of its running time, and anyone expecting the relationship to become physical, or the story to resolve into a clear declaration either way, will find the ambiguity frustrating rather than poignant. Because the script evolved during shooting rather than being locked in advance, some connective material feels thin on close inspection, holding together more through mood and repetition than through causal plotting. The device of rehearsing confrontations with their unfaithful spouses, staged as if-then scenarios between Chow and Su, is effective the first few times but risks feeling like a structural crutch by its later repetitions, standing in for scenes the film otherwise declines to show.

What restraint is doing here

What the film is actually interested in is the gap between what two people feel and what they allow themselves to act on, given that acting on it would make them exactly what their spouses already are. Su’s qipao, ever more restrictive as the film continues, becomes a physical correlative for that self-denial, and the numbered rented rooms and shared landlady’s mahjong games place the affair-that-isn’t inside a community that would notice immediately if it became real. Longing here is treated as its own subject rather than a delay before consummation, and the film’s later detour into Cambodia, where Chow whispers a secret into a hole in a wall at Angkor Wat, extends that idea past the relationship itself into a meditation on what gets carried silently once the moment for saying it has passed.

Who this rewards

This suits viewers who are comfortable with a love story told mostly through glances, costume changes and repeated errands rather than confrontation or dialogue, and who find genuine tension in two people constantly almost saying something. It rewards attention to Doyle’s and Lee’s framing, to Chang’s editing rhythms, and to Cheung’s physical performance more than it rewards attention to plot. It is a poor match for anyone who wants the central relationship to become explicit, wants a resolved ending, or finds slow, repetitive editing tedious rather than hypnotic; the film’s pleasures are cumulative rather than immediate, and viewers looking for incident will likely find the pacing frustrating well before the final act arrives.

Ninety-eight minutes, fully earned

At 98 minutes it never overstays its restraint, and it delivered concretely for those involved: Tony Leung became the first Hong Kong actor to win the Cannes best actor award, and the film took eight prizes from eighteen nominations across other bodies, including Hong Kong Film Awards for both leads. Made on a comparatively modest run that returned 2.7 million dollars at the box office, its reputation has only grown since, reflected in the 92 percent Tomatometer and 87 Metacritic score it holds now, both well above what its quiet, incident-light premise might suggest on paper. It is worth a full, undistracted evening rather than background viewing, since its rewards depend on noticing what is withheld rather than what happens.

Same shelf · Romance4 of 14
Up next in Film

Inside Out

Pete Docter, Ronnie del Carmen · 2015 · 13:00

Pixar turns the inside of an eleven-year-old's head into a workplace comedy, then argues that the console operator worth rooting for is the one nobody wants running things: Sadness.

13:00